Providing smoking cessation support within homelessness services and settings: a co-produced research study

FEATURED, Healthcare, Homelessness, Latest, News, Public Policy, Research

Written by Katie Wood, Commissioning Contracts Officer, Portsmouth City Council

As a public health practitioner working in Portsmouth, one of my roles is to collate information on suspected drug related deaths to look at patterns and trends. These deaths include not just suspected overdoses but any death of a person that is known to our front-line recovery and homelessness services. I will always remember that when reviewing the first 5 deaths when I first came into post, one person had very sadly died from lung cancer and the other 4 people had diagnoses of COPD.  At the time we weren’t collecting information about a person’s smoking status, which is a known risk factor to both.

People experiencing homelessness (PEH) have a shorter life expectancy than the general population, typically dying 30 years younger and there is high rate of smoking amongst the homeless. It is evidenced that quitting smoking can be the single best thing someone can do to improve their health.

I knew that more needed to be done to address the high rates of smoking with PEH, but I just wasn’t sure what. In Portsmouth, during the pandemic as part of the Government’s ‘Everyone in’ policy, Portsmouth’s homeless population were housed in two of the city’s hotels. The smoking cessation service, the Wellbeing Service, were tasked to directly supply vapes or provide access to nicotine replacement products (such as patches and gum) for those staying in the hotels and the support staff; this initially started out due to concerns over the fire risk as some people were reportedly smoking in their rooms. Shortly after the pandemic this provision stopped. 

Two staff from Portsmouth City Council and two researchers from the University of Southampton wanted to find out what stops PEH from quitting smoking, if quitting was important or a priority, and if it was, the type of support that would help them give up. So we went and spoke to staff working in homeless settings and PEH; we visited two homeless hostels and a homeless day service. We did a mixture of group and one-to-one interviews, and some staff were also spoken to online.  

We had a good response and spoke to 32 PEH and 9 members of staff.  I was surprised by the high uptake and willingness of people to share their views. This was actually shared by a member of staff who stated:

‘I’m surprised by the amount of people you’ve had.’

So what did we find?

PEH were aware of the negative impacts to their health and they also had a good awareness on the impact on others’ health; one person stating:

 ‘I’m literally killing myself right now’. 

Improving health was a motivator to quitting, financial gain was less so, as people weren’t sure how much each week they were spending on smoking given they would often share cigarettes or tobacco or even pick up dog ends from the floor.

People had previous negative experiences of quitting, many had attempted to quit, often without any support and often with no nicotine replacement products, going cold turkey, so had struggled, and had limited or no success.

I remember thinking that there was a real appetite for this, and that people experiencing homelessness will not be offended if you ask about their smoking status, they won’t be offended if you offer them support to quit, and if they don’t want to quit they will soon tell you. Offering support could even demonstrate that you are invested in their health and wellbeing. There was only one person that we spoke to that didn’t express a desire to quit.   

Staff assumption that quitting wasn’t a priority for people was one of the many barriers found, so this meant that often people weren’t offered support. Other barriers included the environment in which people lived with many people smoking with their friends and finding that smoking was a social thing; misinformation about local pathways and services; and people still had many misconceptions about the use of vapes and their safety. Many of the people we spoke to smoked to self-medicate with mental health issues such as anxiety, and staff described smoking more at work due to the stress of the job. 

So what would help a person experiencing homelessness to quit?

It was recognised that someone’s internal motivation to quit was key and that a person needed to want to quit. This was linked to where someone might be in their recovery or housing journey with the more settled the person, the more likely the person would want to make changes to their smoking behaviours.

Easy access with support being offered in the places people were already accessing, such as hostels, with free alternative products, such as, vapes was recommended. Personal support and demonstrations on how to use products were also deemed important and very much needed to overcome the previous negative experiences of quitting experienced by many.

The findings of the research were presented at an impact event to service leads and commissioners to co-produce some recommendations.  In total there were five recommendations:

  1. Offering access to free vapes free of charge in homeless settings
  2. Treating vaping differently to smoking – i.e. vape stations  
  3. Training for staff to support them to ask about smoking
  4. Creating smoking cessation champions with staff and residents of hostels
  5. A conscious city wide approach with joint working and collaboration

So what did I learn?

The current referral pathways in Portsmouth may be sufficient to support some people experiencing homelessness to quit, however staff and PEH need to be aware of the local service, and staff need training and support in how to start the conversation as people won’t be offended if they are asked about smoking and support to stop. To really address the high prevalence amongst this population targeted support that is consistent, personable, easily accessed and placed where homeless people are already, with access to free nicotine replacement products such as vapes, is essential. The 32 PEH that we spoke to welcomed the conversation and the opportunity to talk about their smoking behaviours and to have their voices heard; for many it was important to quit and for some a priority. The 9 staff we spoke to were also keen to support any action and there was a real willingness to support their residents if they wanted to be smoke free; for some staff who were current smokers, they were even contemplating a quit attempt if support was offered at their place of work.

Read and download the brief here.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *